0
0
Chelsea Star Sam Kerr Cleared of Racially Aggravated Harassment Charges
Chelsea striker Sam Kerr has been found not guilty of racially aggravated harassment after calling a Metropolitan Police officer “stupid and white.”
A jury at Kingston Crown Court delivered the verdict following a four-hour deliberation regarding an incident in Twickenham, south-west London, on January 30, 2023.
The Incident and Trial
Kerr, 31, stated that she felt “antagonized” by officers after being taken to a police station by a taxi driver following a dispute. The Australian international admitted to using the words “stupid and white” when addressing PC Stephen Lovell but denied it was racially offensive.
The incident unfolded after Kerr and her fiancée, Kristie Mewis, had been out drinking. A taxi driver took them to Twickenham Police Station after a disagreement over clean-up costs when one of them was sick in the vehicle. The driver also alleged that one of them had smashed the car’s rear window.
Courtroom Proceedings
During the trial, Kerr expressed regret over her choice of words but defended the sentiment behind them. She argued that her statement was not an insult based on race but rather an expression of frustration at what she perceived as an abuse of power.
“I believed it was him using his power and privilege over me because he was accusing me of being something I’m not,” Kerr stated in court. “I was trying to express that, due to the power and privilege they had, they would never have to understand what we had just gone through and the fear we were having for our lives.”
The jury ultimately ruled in her favor. After hearing the verdict, Kerr gave a thumbs-up to her legal team before leaving the courtroom with Mewis.
Legal Challenges and Prosecution Scrutiny
It later emerged that Kerr’s legal team had attempted to have the case dismissed before trial, arguing that the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) had violated its own guidelines. Defense lawyer Grace Forbes claimed that a loophole in the victims’ right of review scheme had been used to justify pursuing charges nearly a year after the alleged offense.
Furthermore, the prosecution faced scrutiny over PC Lovell’s statements. Initially, he did not mention any emotional impact from Kerr’s words. However, in a second statement submitted in December 2023, nearly a year after the incident, he claimed the comments had left him “shocked, upset, and feeling humiliated.” This second statement became a key factor in the prosecution’s decision to pursue charges.
Judge’s Remarks
Following the not-guilty verdict, Judge Peter Lodder KC acknowledged that Kerr’s own actions contributed to the situation, stating, “I take the view her own behavior contributed significantly to the bringing of this allegation.” However, he also noted that the jury’s verdict played a crucial role in determining the outcome of the case.
